Tackling SIBO without antibiotics means working on the conditions that let bacteria overgrow in the small intestine, instead of relying on something to kill them. This is often called a low-kill or no-kill approach. In practice it comes down to four things: rebuilding the diversity of the microbiome, restoring the digestive functions that keep bacteria in check, calming a nervous system stuck in fight or flight, and dealing with toxicity and nutrient deficiency.
I took the antibiotics and the antimicrobials myself, and they did not work for me. This is the approach I use now with the people I coach. Whether to take antibiotics is a decision for you and your doctor. What follows is the thinking behind the other route.
Key takeaways
- SIBO is usually a sharp rise in a few species alongside a loss of overall diversity. It is not simply too many bacteria.
- Killing the overgrowth can bring relief, but antibiotics and antimicrobials also reduce diversity, which is one reason relapse is so common.
- Stomach acid, enzymes, bile, motility and the gut lining are the body’s own way of keeping the small intestine clear.
- Those functions are run by the rest-and-digest side of the nervous system, so chronic stress suppresses them.
- Toxicity and nutrient deficiency go hand in hand, and one or the other is nearly always part of the picture.
Why killing the bacteria is often not enough
The mainstream view of SIBO, and of its fungal cousin SIFO, is simple. There are too many bacteria or yeasts in the small intestine, so you kill them with an antibiotic, an antifungal or a herbal antimicrobial such as oil of oregano, and the problem is solved.
If it were that simple, the problem would stay solved. What I see far more often is relapse. Someone takes a course, the breath test comes back negative and the symptoms improve, for a while. Three months later they are back where they started. The same course is repeated because it worked last time. Then it is repeated again. Eventually it stops working altogether.
So the useful question is why relapse is so common, and what a low-kill approach does differently.
SIBO is a loss of diversity as well as an overgrowth
When someone has SIBO or SIFO, you usually see a sharp increase in one type of organism, perhaps two or three. It is a narrow band of species. Look at the microbiome as a whole and you see something else: a significant drop in total diversity.
The lower the diversity, the more likely an overgrowth becomes. And the thing that reduces diversity most is antibiotics, antifungals and other antimicrobial agents. That is the trap. They may give a short-term fix, but the thing that protects you against SIBO is a diverse microbiome, and that is exactly what they wear down.
1. Rebuild the diversity of the microbiome
The first step is to improve diversity, and one of the best ways to do that is with probiotics. I know many people who work with SIBO advise against them. In my opinion that comes from seeing SIBO as too many bacteria overall. It is an overgrowth of a few organisms and a shortage of everything else.
Probiotics do more than add beneficial organisms. They have a strong influence on the make-up of the whole microbiome. Beneficial bacteria produce compounds that hold other bacteria and fungi back, and they take up the space the overgrowth would otherwise move into. Losing them is often how a SIBO picture starts in the first place.
How you introduce them matters. I explain that in why probiotics can make you feel worse, and how to start them.
2. Restore the digestive functions
If your digestion is not doing its job, you are predisposed to SIBO, SIFO and other gut problems. Part of the reason is that bacteria move in as an adaptive response, to help break down the food you are not breaking down yourself.
These are the functions I look at:
- Stomach acid. Low stomach acid lets more microbes through, because acid kills them.
- Digestive enzymes. They break down food, and they also break down biofilms.
- Bile. Thick, sticky bile digests fat poorly. Healthy bile is a potent antimicrobial in its own right.
- Motility. The migrating motor complex sweeps the small intestine clear between meals.
- The gut lining. The mucosa is full of immune cells that shape the microbiome. Unmanaged food sensitivities keep it inflamed, and that function is lost.
Each of these does two jobs. It digests your food, which leaves less for the overgrowth to live on, and it has a killing mechanism built in. That is why a healthy person can drink cup after cup of kefir, with its trillions of bacteria, and not develop SIBO. Their natural cleansing mechanisms are working.
When these functions are corrected, the body gets better at regulating its own flora. My free Gut Health Quiz shows which of the five is most likely to need support, and I go deeper into bile in signs of sluggish bile and what helps.
3. Calm the nervous system
Stomach acid, enzymes, bile, motility and the gut lining are all governed by the parasympathetic nervous system, the rest-and-digest side.
If your body is stuck in a sympathetic state, in fight, flight or freeze, energy is directed towards survival and away from digestion. Every one of those functions is suppressed. You can take all the right supplements and still struggle if the nervous system never switches into the state where digestion happens.
4. Look for toxicity and deficiency
These are the two causes I see most. There is usually a mix of the factors above, and nearly always one or other of these as well. They go hand in hand, because a deficiency allows toxins to build up, and a toxic exposure uses up nutrients.
Mercury and selenium are a simple example. The body uses selenium in dealing with mercury, so exposure to mercury runs selenium down. Now there are two problems. Selenium is closely tied to the thyroid, a slower thyroid means slower motility, and slow motility is one of the routes into SIBO. It works the other way round as well. If your diet is low in selenium, even small exposures to mercury can build up over time, because the mechanism for clearing them is missing.
Different toxins deplete different nutrients, and different deficiencies let different toxins accumulate. Toxicity also suppresses the immune system and inflames the gut, and many toxins act like antibiotics. Mold is the obvious case. Penicillin was discovered when mold landed in a dish and killed the bacteria growing in it. If you are living with mold exposure, those toxins are affecting your microbiome in a similar way. I cover this in why mold makes some people sick and not others and in the five root causes of SIBO I see most.
More nuanced, but not complicated
I know this sounds more involved than taking an antibiotic or a herbal antimicrobial. It is more nuanced. It is not complicated. It is a matter of understanding how the body naturally protects itself against this kind of problem, and working out where that system has broken down.
Nobody has an antibiotic deficiency. There is an imbalance somewhere in the systems above, and a lasting result depends on finding it.
Video: I explain how a low-kill approach deals with SIBO and SIFO.
Frequently asked questions
Can SIBO go away without antibiotics?
In my experience many people improve when the underlying causes are addressed: low diversity, weak digestive function, a stressed nervous system, and toxicity or deficiency. I cannot promise a result, and whether to take antibiotics is a decision for you and your doctor.
What is a low-kill or no-kill SIBO protocol?
It is an approach that focuses on restoring the body’s own defences against overgrowth instead of relying on antibiotics or antimicrobials to kill bacteria. The aim is to change the conditions that allowed the overgrowth.
Why does SIBO come back after antibiotics?
Antibiotics reduce the overgrowth, but they also reduce the diversity of the microbiome, and they do not change what caused the problem. If digestion, the nervous system or a toxic exposure is still out of balance, the overgrowth tends to return.
Should I take probiotics if I have SIBO?
Many practitioners advise against it. My view is that SIBO involves a loss of diversity, and probiotics are one of the best ways to rebuild it. Start low, introduce one at a time and go slowly.
Can stress cause SIBO to return?
It can contribute. Stomach acid, enzymes, bile and motility are run by the rest-and-digest side of the nervous system. When the body is stuck in fight or flight, those functions are suppressed.
Next step
Want the full process, step by step?
My SIBO Recovery Protocol sets out what I would tell you in a consultation, in the order that works: finding your cause, rebuilding digestion and gut flora, and calming the nervous system. The free Gut Health Quiz shows which of the five pillars needs support.
Keep reading
Research mentioned in this article
- Hofmann A.F. and Eckmann L. (2006). How bile acids confer gut mucosal protection against bacteria. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.
I’m a coach, not a medical doctor. This article shares my experience and what I see with the clients I coach. It is for education only and is not medical advice, a diagnosis or a treatment plan. Speak to your doctor before changing medication or if your symptoms are severe or new.