Probiotics vs fermented foods is one of the questions my clients ask me most. My short answer: if you tolerate them, fermented foods come first for me, because they bring a wide range of microbes together with the food itself. A probiotic supplement makes more sense when you react to ferments, as many people with histamine intolerance do, or when you want specific strains.

Key takeaways

  • Fermented foods such as sauerkraut, kimchi and homemade yoghurt are my first choice for people who tolerate them.
  • They give you a broad mix of microbes, and making them at home costs far less than supplements.
  • Probiotic supplements are more targeted: you choose the strains and the amount.
  • Fermented foods are high in histamine. If you have histamine intolerance, a carefully chosen probiotic is usually the easier place to start.
  • It does not have to be one or the other. What matters is what your gut tolerates.

Why fermented foods are my first choice

Fermented foods such as sauerkraut, kimchi and homemade yoghurt carry a wide range of microbes, and they arrive together with the food they grew in. That natural diversity is the main reason I put them first. You are not adding one or two strains. You are adding a whole community.

If you have the time, try making them at home. You control what goes in, you can vary your ferments to widen the range of microbes, and it costs far less than buying probiotic supplements.

Check this recipe: Sauerkraut

When a probiotic supplement makes more sense

Fermented foods are not for everyone. That is where probiotics come in. A supplement is a more targeted approach: you know which strains you are taking and how much, which matters when you are dealing with a specific problem.

Take histamine intolerance. Fermented foods are high in histamine, so many people with histamine intolerance react to them. A probiotic gives you a more controlled way to bring in beneficial bacteria, one strain at a time. Even then, start low and go slowly. I explain how in why probiotics can make you feel worse, and how to start them.

Watch this video: Why Do We Need Probiotics: The #1 Guide Unveiled!

What fermentation does

During fermentation, bacteria turn the sugars in the food into lactic acid. The lactic acid preserves the food naturally and holds back the bacteria you do not want.

When you eat fermented vegetables, sauerkraut or a fermented salsa, you are feeding your gut a varied mix of microorganisms, which supports the diversity of your own microbiome.

My verdict

For most people who tolerate them, fermented foods come first for me, because of their natural diversity and the nutrition that comes with them. Probiotics still have their place, especially if you have a specific need or cannot tolerate ferments. Plenty of people use both. It comes down to what works for your gut.

Video: I compare probiotics and fermented foods and explain when I use each.

Frequently asked questions

Are fermented foods better than probiotics?

For most people who tolerate them, I put fermented foods first. They contain a wider range of microbes than a supplement and they come with the food itself. Probiotics are more useful when you need specific strains or cannot tolerate ferments.

Can I take probiotics and eat fermented foods at the same time?

Yes. It does not have to be one or the other, and many people use both. Introduce one new thing at a time, so that you can tell what your gut is reacting to.

Why do fermented foods make me feel worse?

Fermented foods are high in histamine. If you have histamine intolerance they can trigger reactions, and in that case a carefully chosen probiotic is usually an easier place to start.

Is homemade sauerkraut better than shop-bought?

Often, yes. Many shop-bought ferments are pasteurised or preserved with vinegar, which means most of the live bacteria are lost. Homemade sauerkraut, or an unpasteurised one, keeps them.

Next step

Want to see where your digestion is getting stuck?

The free Gut Health Quiz shows which of the five pillars of digestion needs support. The Gut Health Bundle then takes you through each one, step by step.

Take the free quizSee the Gut Health Bundle

William Dickinson, gut health coach

Written by

William Dickinson

I’m a gut health coach from the UK. I spent years unwell with gut, histamine and mold problems before I worked out how to turn them around, and I now coach clients worldwide through the same process. I have worked with more than 1,000 clients and taught over 425 online classes.

More about me

I’m a coach, not a medical doctor. This article shares my experience and what I see with the clients I coach. It is for education only and is not medical advice, a diagnosis or a treatment plan. Speak to your doctor before changing medication or if your symptoms are severe or new.