A SIBO breath test measures the gases that bacteria in your gut produce after you drink a sugar solution: hydrogen, methane and sometimes hydrogen sulphide. In my experience it rarely tells you anything your symptoms have not already told you, and it says nothing about why the overgrowth is there. That is why the result seldom changes what I do.

If your doctor has asked for a breath test, have it. This is my view, as a coach, of how much weight to give the result and what to look at alongside it.

Key takeaways

  • A breath test shows whether gut bacteria are producing gas from a sugar, and which gas.
  • Symptoms usually point the same way: a lot of gas and loose stools with hydrogen, constipation and fullness with methane, a sulphur smell with hydrogen sulphide.
  • The test cannot tell you why the bacteria overgrew.
  • SIBO is not a root cause. Something has disrupted one of the five pillars of digestion.
  • I find it more useful to think of an imbalance in the small intestine than of an overgrowth to be killed.

What a breath test measures

For a breath test you drink a solution of glucose or lactulose and then breathe into a device at intervals. If bacteria in the small intestine ferment the sugar, the gases they produce show up in your breath. The test reports whether there is gas and which kind: hydrogen, methane or, with some tests, hydrogen sulphide.

It often costs somewhere between 100 and 250 in pounds, dollars or euros. What you get for that is a yes or a no to one question: when you eat fermentable carbohydrate, do you produce gas?

Most people with these symptoms know the answer already. If high-FODMAP foods and prebiotic fibres set you off, you have in effect been running the test at every meal.

What your symptoms already tell you

The type of gas can usually be read from the symptoms.

  • Hydrogen. A larger volume of gas, and a tendency towards diarrhoea.
  • Methane. If you are producing methane, you are producing hydrogen as well. Another group of organisms, the methanogens, consumes the hydrogen and turns it into methane. You still have plenty of gas, and you tend to have a motility problem: little appetite, feeling full very quickly, or constipation.
  • Hydrogen sulphide. You can smell it. It is the rotten-egg smell.

So I ask what the test adds. In most cases the answer is very little.

What the SIBO label got right

I will give the label this much. Until fairly recently SIBO was hardly talked about. People were told they had IBS, which means your bowels are irritable, nobody knows why, and perhaps you should eat more fibre.

SIBO is one step closer to something useful. It says the symptoms may be connected to the bacteria in the small intestine, that more fibre may not be the best idea for you, and that a low FODMAP diet might help for a while. That is progress.

Why I prefer “imbalance” to “overgrowth”

My problem with the label is what it leads to. You hear “small intestinal bacterial overgrowth” and you think: bacteria are overgrowing, so they need to be killed. A positive test tends to be followed by antibiotics or a long course of antimicrobial herbs.

I find it more helpful to think of a small intestinal imbalance. When the organisms in the gut are wiped out, the imbalance usually gets worse, not better. An imbalance in bacteria also often comes with an imbalance in yeasts and fungi, which a bacterial breath test does not look at.

My own story is the reason I feel strongly about this. After a positive breath test I took antibiotics, followed by months of antimicrobial herbs. It was one of the things that tipped me from a gut problem into chronic fatigue, several autoimmune problems and a diet of five foods. That is my experience and not a prediction for anyone else, and whether to take antibiotics is a decision for you and your doctor. I explain the alternative in how a low-kill approach works.

SIBO is never the root cause

In functional and alternative health everyone says to chase the root cause, and then tells you that your root cause is SIBO. It is not. SIBO is an adaptive response or a downstream symptom. There is always something behind it.

That something shows up as a problem in one of the five pillars of digestion: stomach acid, digestive enzymes, bile, motility or the gut lining. You cannot have SIBO without an imbalance in the microbiome, and you do not get that imbalance without one of these being off.

So the work is to trace it back, support the pillar that is struggling and then help the microbiome to rebalance. A breath test does none of that. The causes I find most often are in why SIBO keeps coming back, and my free Gut Health Quiz shows which pillar is most likely to need attention.

Where antimicrobials fit

I am not saying they should never be used. My point is that they belong at the end and not at the start.

I have worked with many people who went straight to antibiotics, antimicrobials and antifungals. For a small number it worked. For others it worked for a while, perhaps a year, and then everything came back, because the cause was untouched.

One client of mine with gut and histamine problems did it the other way round. We built up probiotics and digestive support first, over about six months, and he made considerable progress. Only then did he use an antimicrobial, for the last layer, with guidance. By that point his digestion could cope, and it helped.

Video: my view of SIBO breath testing and of the SIBO label.

Frequently asked questions

How accurate is a SIBO breath test?

Breath tests can give both false positives and false negatives, and practitioners differ in how they read them. My reservation is more practical: the result rarely changes what needs to be done.

What is the difference between hydrogen and methane SIBO?

Hydrogen tends to come with a lot of gas and looser stools. Methane is produced by organisms that consume hydrogen, and it tends to come with slow motility, fullness and constipation.

Can I tell whether I have SIBO without a test?

Your symptoms can point strongly in that direction, especially reactions to fermentable foods. A diagnosis is for a doctor, and persistent or severe gut symptoms should always be checked.

Should I take antibiotics after a positive breath test?

That is a decision for you and your doctor. My view is that whatever you take, the result tends not to last unless the reason for the overgrowth is dealt with.

Next step

Want the full process, step by step?

My SIBO Recovery Protocol sets out what I would tell you in a consultation, in the order that works: finding your cause, rebuilding digestion and gut flora, and calming the nervous system. The free Gut Health Quiz shows which of the five pillars needs support.

See the protocolTake the free quiz

William Dickinson, gut health coach

Written by

William Dickinson

I’m a gut health coach from the UK. I spent years unwell with gut, histamine and mold problems before I worked out how to turn them around, and I now coach clients worldwide through the same process. I have worked with more than 1,000 clients and taught over 425 online classes.

More about me

I’m a coach, not a medical doctor. This article shares my experience and what I see with the clients I coach. It is for education only and is not medical advice, a diagnosis or a treatment plan. Speak to your doctor before changing medication or if your symptoms are severe or new.