Probiotics can make you feel worse when you first take them, even though they are live bacteria that help you digest food and look after the lining of your gut. In my experience that almost always means the dose is too high for where your body is right now. It does not mean probiotics are wrong for you.

It took me close to three years to build up to a full dose. Here is what probiotics do, why they can cause a reaction, and how I start my clients on them.

Key takeaways

  • Most of the organisms in your gut are helpful. Probiotics add to the ones that digest food and protect the gut lining.
  • Traditionally fermented foods are a natural source. Powders and capsules are far stronger and need more care.
  • A reaction happens when the organisms already in your gut release more toxins than your body can clear.
  • Feeling awful is not a sign that it is working. It is a sign you have gone past your limit.
  • Lower the dose until there is no reaction, stay there for a few days to a week, then increase slowly.

What do probiotics do?

Your small and large intestine are home to bacteria, yeasts and many other organisms. Most of them are helpful and protective, so the aim is never to wipe them out.

The helpful ones do several jobs. They produce enzymes that help break down your food. Beyond that, they take part in keeping the gut lining intact, and that lining is the barrier between what you eat and the rest of your body. They also keep less friendly organisms in check.

What a particular strain does varies from person to person. A probiotic that suits one person can be the wrong one for someone else, which is why your own experience is the best guide.

Where do probiotics come from?

People have always eaten probiotics in traditionally prepared fermented foods:

  • Dairy: live yoghurt, kefir, traditionally made cheese and cultured butter.
  • Vegetables: sauerkraut and kimchi.
  • Meat: traditionally cured chorizo and salami.

Heat destroys probiotics, so these foods only count when they have not been cooked or pasteurised after fermenting. With whole foods you also get the enzymes and acids the bacteria have already produced, so part of the digestion is done before you eat.

Probiotic powders and capsules are much more concentrated. They are useful, and they deserve respect. If you are chronically unwell, even a spoonful of live yoghurt can be too much at first.

Why can probiotics make you feel worse?

The amount of bacteria in a probiotic is tiny next to what already lives in your gut. If that existing flora is out of balance, it is part of why you have symptoms in the first place.

When new organisms arrive, the ones already there do not move out quietly. They compete, and as they fight and die they release toxins. One well-studied example is LPS, a fragment of certain gut bacteria that researchers have linked to fatigue and low mood. There are many others.

If your gut lining is leaky, more of those compounds get through. The result is usually a flare of whatever you already had. For one person that is joint pain. For another it is a skin flare, anxiety or low mood. People also describe fatigue, headaches, body aches, nausea, brain fog and irritability.

This is often called a Herxheimer or die-off reaction.

Why pushing through a reaction does not work

Picture your capacity to clear toxins as a cup. Your liver does most of that work. While what comes in stays below the rim, you feel nothing, even though the probiotic is doing its job. Go over the rim and the cup spills. That spill is what you feel.

In natural health circles a bad reaction is often treated as a good sign. I disagree. If you feel awful, you have pushed your body past what it can handle, and that does not speed anything up. It slows you down, and most people simply stop taking the probiotic.

Your body is what heals you. If what you are doing makes it feel worse, you are going too fast.

How I start clients on probiotics

1. Lower the dose until there is no reaction

For sensitive people I go very low. Take an eighth of the small scoop, stir it into a full glass of water, and drink one sip. If that is what you tolerate without a reaction, that is your starting dose. It helps you more than a full scoop that makes you ill.

2. Stay there, then increase slowly

Hold that dose for a few days to a week. Then increase a little and see how you respond. If symptoms come back, step down again. A slight awareness that something is happening is fine. Feeling bad is not.

3. Support your body so the cup gets bigger

The body is good at clearing toxins when it has what it needs. Depending on the person, that can mean working on digestion itself, or simple things like hot baths, a sauna, Epsom salts or magnesium. Fasting and vegetable juices help some people too. Probiotics are a big part of gut health, and they are not all of it.

4. Look at the emotional side

A few people cannot tolerate even one sip. When that happens I usually find there is emotional work to do as well. Healing has more than one layer, and the physical one is only the first.

Video: why probiotics can make you feel bad, and the dose I start with.

How long does it take to build up?

It took me two and a half to three years to reach a full dose, one sip at a time. I was very unwell when I started, and I learned the hard way that forcing it only set me back.

Most people are quicker. I have had clients reach a full dose in three weeks, in three months, in six months and in a year. It depends on where you are starting from, and there is no prize for speed.

Frequently asked questions

Is it normal to feel worse when you start taking probiotics?

It is common, especially if your gut is already out of balance. In my experience it means the dose is higher than your body can handle at the moment. Lowering the dose usually settles it.

What is a Herxheimer or die-off reaction?

It is the name people give to feeling worse after starting something that changes the gut flora. As the existing organisms compete and die they release toxins, and if your body cannot clear them fast enough you feel it.

Should I push through die-off symptoms?

I do not recommend it. Feeling awful means you have gone past your limit. It does not speed up the process, and most people give up as a result. Reduce the dose to a level that causes no reaction.

How much probiotic should I start with?

As little as it takes to feel no reaction. For very sensitive people I start at an eighth of a small scoop stirred into a glass of water, and one sip from that glass. Stay there for a few days to a week before increasing.

Are fermented foods enough, or do I need a supplement?

Traditionally fermented foods such as live yoghurt, kefir and sauerkraut are a good natural source. Powders and capsules are far more concentrated, which makes them useful when the gut needs more support, but they need more care.

Which probiotic do you use?

I usually start clients on a lactobacillus and bifidobacterium blend in powder form, because the dose is easy to adjust. The one I use is in the video above. I have no affiliation with the company.

Next step

Probiotics are one part of the picture.

The Gut Health Bundle covers the whole chain, from stomach acid to the microbiome, so you can see where your digestion is getting stuck and what to work on first.

See the Gut Health BundleWork with me

Research mentioned in this article

William Dickinson, gut health coach

Written by

William Dickinson

I’m a gut health coach from the UK. I spent years unwell with gut, histamine and mold problems before I worked out how to turn them around, and I now coach clients worldwide through the same process. I have worked with more than 1,000 clients and taught over 425 online classes.

More about me

I’m a coach, not a medical doctor. This article shares my experience and what I see with the clients I coach. It is for education only and is not medical advice, a diagnosis or a treatment plan. Speak to your doctor before changing medication or if your symptoms are severe or new.