Eating enough to heal is the factor I see neglected most in people with complex chronic health problems: several autoimmune conditions at once, chronic fatigue, fibromyalgia, symptoms in more than one body system. Every part of recovery costs energy. Immune function, detoxification and tissue repair all run on calories, and when there are not enough, the body turns those jobs down first. You can get everything else right and still stall if you are under-eating.

It was one of the biggest factors in my own recovery. This is not advice to force food down or to ignore medical guidance. If you have a history of disordered eating, diabetes or another condition that affects how you should eat, work this out with your doctor or dietitian.

Key takeaways

  • Healing is expensive. Immune function, detoxification and repair all need energy.
  • In a calorie deficit the body slows everything down, and the immune system is one of the first things to be turned down.
  • Under-eating on its own can cause fatigue and poor sleep, and it can make food reactions worse.
  • Between a third and a half of the people who come to me are eating less than 1,800 calories a day.
  • The simplest fix is usually more of the foods you already tolerate, especially fats and carbohydrates.

Everything in recovery costs energy

Most advice on chronic illness is about the gut, nutrients and deficiencies. All of that matters. Almost nobody talks about how much you are eating, and if that is wrong, the rest struggles to work.

Calories are simply units of energy, and every healing function in the body uses them. Immune activity uses them. So does detoxification, repairing damaged tissue and breaking down scar tissue.

Say you are working on your liver. You eat very cleanly, you take the right support and your gut is doing well, but you are not eating enough. Your basic metabolic rate drops, and with it the rate of everything else. I have worked with a great many people, and I very rarely see healing happen in a calorie deficit. It makes sense. Healing needs abundance, and a deficit is the opposite of that.

Eating enough to heal: how much is enough?

As a general reference, an average woman needs around 2,000 calories a day and an average man around 2,500. Someone recovering from a chronic health problem has more work for the body to do, so I look for at least that much and usually a little more. Your own needs depend on your size, your activity and your situation. Treat these numbers as a guide and not as a prescription.

If you fast as part of your routine, the calories you miss have to go back in on the other days. Fasting is not about being in a deficit. Its value is in the time the body spends in a different metabolic state. I explain how I approach it in fasting for beginners.

What under-eating looks like

Take a completely healthy person, put them on a calorie-restricted diet, and they develop problems. Their energy disappears and their sleep gets worse. That is simply what happens when the body does not have enough fuel.

So some of the symptoms you put down to your illness may have nothing to do with it. They may be what happens to anyone who is not eating enough. When you have several health problems at once, it is hard to tell which symptom belongs to what.

Between a third and a half of the people who come to work with me are eating less than 1,800 calories a day. That is very low. If you are exhausted and trying to recover with adaptogens, nervous system work and meditation, but you are not eating enough, your body does not have the energy to feel safe. The two most helpful things for that kind of exhaustion are enough sleep and enough food.

Under-eating and food sensitivities

Digestion costs energy as well. Producing stomach acid, making and releasing enzymes, packaging toxins into bile and emulsifying fat all use calories.

I have seen people develop reactions to whole food groups mainly because they were not eating enough. The body has the machinery to process histamine, salicylates or oxalates, but not the energy to run it. That looks like a food sensitivity. Give the body more resources and its capacity goes up.

In some cases I have seen severe histamine, salicylate or oxalate reactions ease to mild, or to nothing, in as little as two weeks, after the person increased what they ate by 800 or 900 calories a day. It does not happen for everyone, but it is worth knowing before you cut out yet another food.

Feed yourself first

People who know how important the microbiome is often focus on feeding their gut bacteria with fibre, vegetables and polyphenols. That matters. But feed yourself first.

Your gut flora is shaped by the state of your immune system, and the immune system is one of the most expensive things the body runs. Think about what happens when a strong, healthy person catches something. They produce a fever, and that uses an enormous amount of energy. A body that is short of calories will not spend energy that way. It is saving it to stay alive.

The body needs a surplus before it feels safe enough to mount a strong immune response or to detoxify in earnest.

How to eat more when your diet is restricted

I know how hard this is with food sensitivities. For about five years I could eat only about five foods without reacting. I also had gastritis, and my stomach could manage roughly a cupful of food at a time. Any more set off digestive problems and a chain of other reactions. So I ate a cupful four times a day, and on a good day I reached about 2,800 calories. It made a profound difference to my fatigue, my gut and my autoimmune symptoms.

This is what I suggest:

  • Eat more of what you already tolerate. You know your safe foods. That is the easiest place to find more calories.
  • Lean on fats. Fat has nine calories per gram. Protein and carbohydrate have four. Increasing fat raises your total quickly, as long as your digestion can handle it.
  • Use carbohydrates and fats for fuel, and protein for its own jobs. Protein matters for detoxification, repair and muscle, but it is a poor source of energy. Do not try to raise your calories with protein.
  • Do not avoid a food only because the internet says so. If you have been avoiding all carbohydrates and you feel the same or better when you eat them, eat them. Your body tells you with every meal whether something is helping.
  • Track one day. You do not need to count every day. Once every couple of weeks, write down or log everything you eat and see where you are.

Listen to your body

How you feel is the best guide you have. More energy, better sleep and a better mood mean you are moving in the right direction. Feeling worse means something needs to change.

The idea of calories in and calories out is too simple. The body is a biochemical machine and not a furnace, which I explain in the truth about calories. But the body still needs energy to heal, and recovery is hard enough already. Do not make it harder by under-eating.

Video: I explain why calorie intake matters so much in chronic fatigue, fibromyalgia and autoimmune conditions.

Frequently asked questions

Can you heal while eating in a calorie deficit?

I very rarely see it. Immune function, detoxification and tissue repair all need energy, and they are among the first things the body turns down when it is short of calories.

How many calories do I need when recovering from chronic illness?

As a general reference, around 2,000 a day for an average woman and 2,500 for an average man, and often a little more during recovery. Your needs depend on your size, activity and situation, so treat that as a guide and get individual advice if you are unsure.

Can under-eating cause food sensitivities?

In my experience it can make them worse. Digesting and processing compounds such as histamine takes energy. I have seen reactions ease in some people within weeks of eating more.

How do I eat more on a restricted diet?

Start with larger or more frequent portions of the foods you already tolerate, and add fat, which is the most concentrated source of calories. Tracking a single day shows you where you are.

Should I eat more protein to get more calories?

No. Protein is needed for repair and detoxification, but it is a poor fuel. Fats and carbohydrates are what the body prefers to run on.

Next step

Not sure what your body needs first?

The free Gut Health Quiz shows which part of your digestion needs support. If you would like me to look at your whole picture, including what you are eating, book a Root Cause Consultation.

Take the free quizWork with me

William Dickinson, gut health coach

Written by

William Dickinson

I’m a gut health coach from the UK. I spent years unwell with gut, histamine and mold problems before I worked out how to turn them around, and I now coach clients worldwide through the same process. I have worked with more than 1,000 clients and taught over 425 online classes.

More about me

I’m a coach, not a medical doctor. This article shares my experience and what I see with the clients I coach. It is for education only and is not medical advice, a diagnosis or a treatment plan. Speak to your doctor before changing medication or if your symptoms are severe or new.