The truth about calories is that they measure energy in a laboratory, not what your body does with food. Two meals with the same number of calories can affect you very differently, depending on what they are made of, how well you digest them and what your body needs at the time. Counting calories has its uses, but on its own it misses most of what matters.
Key takeaways
- A calorie is a unit of heat measured in a laboratory. The body is not a furnace.
- Protein, fat and carbohydrate do different jobs, so the same calories can have different effects.
- Eating too little for too long slows metabolism and makes weight loss harder.
- What you absorb depends on your digestion, not only on what is on the label.
- Whole foods, meal timing and eating enough matter more than the number.
What is a calorie?
A calorie is a unit of energy. It is the amount of heat needed to raise the temperature of one gram of water by one degree Celsius[1].
But here’s the thing: our bodies are not burning the food we eat. Our bodies are incredibly complex biochemical machines that perform thousands of processes every day, using various chemicals and compounds with different levels of efficiency, based on our unique genetic and epigenetic differences.
My view of health and weight is simple: the body is far more intelligent than a sum. To see why, it helps to look at what the macronutrients actually do.
Fat has more than twice the calories per gram of protein or carbohydrate. It is also how the body chooses to store spare energy, which tells you something about how well it works as a fuel.
Protein and fat do different jobs
The body is not simply burning calories, and sorting food into macronutrients is an oversimplification too. Protein, for example, is made up of amino acids with different purposes. Collagen is used for the structure of bone and skin, and cysteine for building sulphur compounds.
So protein is not just fuel. The body needs it for building and repair, and it will turn to fat for energy when it can.
Fat has structural roles as well, such as the omega-3 fats in the nervous system, but it is the body’s main energy store.
Metabolism is not a furnace
The numbers on a food label come from burning food in a laboratory. Your body does not burn food. It runs a series of chemical reactions that are far more complex, and how efficiently they run varies from person to person and from day to day.
What happens when you under-eat
Many people cut calories very low to lose weight, and under-nourish themselves in the process. The body responds by conserving energy. Metabolism slows, repair slows, energy and concentration drop, and losing weight becomes harder, not easier.
The truth about calories: digestion decides what you absorb
What you absorb matters more than what is on the label. Bioavailability is the share of the nutrition in a food that your body can actually take in. Two foods can contain the same amount of protein and deliver very different amounts to you. Anti-nutrients in plants, such as lectins and tannins, can make protein harder to absorb[2], and the state of your digestion matters just as much.
Calories are not everything, and focusing on them too closely can backfire. I would rather you focused on whole foods, on when you eat and on eating enough. If you want to go deeper into anti-nutrients, I have a full article on them.
Read this article too: Anti-Nutrients in Vegetables: How Plants Fight Back and What to Do
Long periods of under-eating are hard on the body. Put your health first and let your weight follow. If you have a medical condition or a history of disordered eating, get advice from your doctor before changing how much you eat.
Frequently asked questions
Are all calories the same?
On a label, yes. In the body, no. Protein, fat and carbohydrate are used for different purposes, and how much you absorb depends on the food and on your digestion.
Why am I not losing weight on a low-calorie diet?
One common reason is that the body adapts. When calories stay very low for a long time, it conserves energy and metabolism slows, which makes further weight loss harder.
Should I stop counting calories?
Counting can be a useful check, but it should not be the only thing you look at. Food quality, meal timing, eating enough and how well you digest all matter.
Next step
Want to see where your digestion is getting stuck?
The free Gut Health Quiz shows which of the five pillars of digestion needs support. The Gut Health Bundle then takes you through each one, step by step.
Keep reading
I’m a coach, not a medical doctor. This article shares my experience and what I see with the clients I coach. It is for education only and is not medical advice, a diagnosis or a treatment plan. Speak to your doctor before changing medication or if your symptoms are severe or new.