Low stomach acid can be supported without betaine HCl. I do not tolerate betaine HCl myself, and I still built an extremely strong digestive system. I started with what to stop: drinking with meals and eating protein with starch. Then I made sure I had enough salt and cooked my food until it was easy to break down. Broth, enzymes and fermented foods are the next layer.
If you know that low stomach acid is part of your chronic digestive problems, finding out that you cannot take betaine HCl can feel as if there is nothing left to do. That is not true. There is plenty you can do.
Key takeaways
- Stomach acid triggers the whole digestive cascade. It influences bile, digestive enzymes and the microflora of the small intestine.
- Not everybody tolerates betaine HCl. I am one of them.
- Four things almost everybody can do: stop drinking with meals, keep protein away from starch, eat enough good-quality salt and cook protein until it falls apart.
- The next layer is broth for the stomach lining, a digestive enzyme with proteases that work across pH ranges, and fermented foods and probiotics.
- I could not do anything in the second layer, and the first four were enough to rebuild my stomach acid.
Why low stomach acid matters
Stomach acid is one of the most important physiological parts of the digestive system, because it triggers the whole digestive cascade. It influences your bile production and your production of digestive enzymes, and it strongly influences the microflora, especially in the small intestine.
The easiest way to support it is to take betaine HCl. This is a supplement that is physiologically identical to the acid we produce in our own stomach, so we can quite literally do the job of stomach acid by taking a pill. But not everybody tolerates it, and I am one of them.
Before I give you things to do, I am going to give you things to stop. I start here because very sensitive people may not be able to do everything on this list, but everybody can stop doing the things that weaken stomach acid. They do not require you to do anything.
1. Stop drinking liquids with your meals
This is the first and the most impactful. Ideally you would avoid drinking anything from 15 minutes before a meal, for the whole of the meal, and for 45 minutes to an hour afterwards.
Even though you cannot handle extra acid, you can do as much as possible to avoid diluting the acid your body is already producing. The pH scale is logarithmic. I will not go into the detail, but what you need to know is that drinking even half a glass of pH 7 water means your stomach has to work 10,000 to a million times harder. Simply avoiding excess liquid with your meal is an amazing way to support your stomach acid.
2. Stop eating protein with starch
Proteins and animal products such as chicken, beef and eggs need a very strong acid to be digested correctly. Starches need very little acid. They need a pH of 7 to 8. When you eat these two food groups together, you create a conflicting need for digestive machinery that is incompatible.
For a person with a strong digestive system this is no problem. If yours is struggling, simply avoid eating protein and animal products with starchy foods: potatoes, rice, pasta, any wheat products, and pseudo-grains such as quinoa. It does not mean you cannot eat these foods. It means you do not eat them together. Have your starch in one meal and your protein in another, so the body can do one thing at a time instead of doing all of them badly.
Protein and animal products are fine with non-starchy vegetables and fats. Have them with a salad or in a soup. Greens and carrots are fine, and so are pumpkin and butternut squash. It also helps to include fat with protein, because in nature wherever you have a lot of protein you have fat alongside it. Egg yolks, tallow, lard, olive oil and coconut oil all help you to digest protein. I explain the rest of this in the food combining rules I use.
3. Eat enough good-quality salt
Stomach acid is hydrochloric acid, and salt is sodium chloride. By having enough good-quality salt in your diet, you provide one of the raw building blocks your body uses to make stomach acid.
This is not rocket science. Add good-quality salt to your food to taste. It should taste nice. If it tastes too salty, you have too much. If it tastes bland, you do not have enough. Your body is a biofeedback mechanism, and how the food tastes is telling you how much sodium chloride you need. Do not overthink it and do not measure it.
4. Cook protein until it falls apart
The way you prepare food significantly influences the digestive machinery you need to break it down. Think how hard it is to pull apart a raw chicken breast with your fingers. That is how much acid it needs. A chicken breast that has been boiled or steamed for four, five or six hours falls apart under its own weight, and it needs that much less acid.
So think about how you prepare your proteins and animal products. A boiled egg is much harder to digest than very soft scrambled eggs. You do not have to make it complicated. You can look at a food and taste it and get an idea of how hard it will be for your stomach acid to digest. Make it a little easier. Your body has to work that much less hard, which means it does that much better a job.
Almost everybody should be able to do all four of these. Do not get hung up on the things you cannot do.
5. Strengthen the stomach lining with broth
The next layer is made of things you can add. If you cannot do them, do not worry. I was extremely sensitive. I could not take betaine HCl and I could not do anything in this second layer either, and I still improved my stomach acid.
The first is to strengthen the mucosal barrier. This is especially good for people with gastritis or any kind of mucosal problem, such as leaky gut. Sometimes the body is able to produce more stomach acid and does not, because it is intelligent. It knows that the mucus is not strong enough to handle more acid, and it does not want to digest and erode the stomach lining, so it reduces the amount it produces. If you make the mucosa stronger, your body will feel comfortable producing more acid.
One of the best ways to do this is with broth. Broth contains a lot of substances that help the gut lining to heal, including glutamine, glycosaminoglycans and other glycoproteins. They are mucilaginous, so they provide the building blocks and also act as a kind of artificial mucus that does the job of the mucosa. Broth is well salted, and it stimulates the appetite and stimulates the body to produce more stomach acid, in the same way that digestive bitters stimulate enzymes and bile. Animal products, and especially pre-digested animal products like broth, do exactly that for the stomach.
If you have histamine problems, broth needs care. People with digestive problems often have histamine intolerance as well, and I was one of them. There are ways round it, and I describe how I make broth in my low histamine diet tips.
6. Take a digestive enzyme with proteases that work at any pH
Look for a digestive enzyme that contains proteases, and ideally a Thera-blend. A Thera-blend is a blend of enzymes that work at different pH ranges. They work whether your stomach acid is low, normal or high, and they keep working in the small intestine, where the pH is buffered by bicarbonate and is far more alkaline.
My absolute favourite is Digest Gold by Enzymedica. It is a full-spectrum digestive enzyme, and it contains a Thera-blend of proteases. Even if your acid levels are low, you are hacking protein digestion by digesting the protein through a different mechanism.
This matters because a protein deficiency affects every function in your body, including stomach acid secretion, detoxification, appetite and motility. An enzyme improves protein digestion without directly changing the pH in the stomach. Changing the pH is the long-term goal, but in the short term it does not always work, and this is the way round it.
7. Bring in fermented foods and probiotics
I was extremely sensitive, and my favourite probiotic for sensitive people is the D-Lactate Free probiotic. In the long run, fermented foods are definitely better. They contain natural acids that support stomach acid secretion and temporarily do the job for you, and they contain a lot of digestive enzymes and organisms that rebalance the microbiome.
If you have low stomach acid, the likelihood of dysbiotic and pathogenic organisms living in your stomach is extremely high. I am not a big fan of trying to kill things directly. I prefer to put the correct things back. Probiotics and fermented foods contain Lactobacillus and other species that improve the microbial balance in the stomach, encourage it to heal, and allow it to build up its mucosal lining and begin to produce the correct levels of stomach acid again.
If you are extremely sensitive and do not know where to start, start with probiotics. I go through the types, the dosages and how to bring in fermented foods in how I start probiotics, and I compare the two in probiotics and fermented foods.
If you can only do the first four
They are enough. I could not take betaine HCl and I could not do anything in the second layer, and I still improved my stomach acid to the point where I have an extremely strong digestive system. It is not perfect. But the question of whether I have enough stomach acid literally never enters my mind.
If you do take betaine HCl, everything here complements it. Wherever you are, there is always something you can do. You only need to work out a way to strategise around it.
Video: the steps I use to support stomach acid when betaine HCl is not an option.
Frequently asked questions
Should I drink water with meals if I have low stomach acid?
No. I avoid drinking from 15 minutes before a meal until 45 minutes to an hour after it. Even half a glass of pH 7 water means the stomach has to work 10,000 to a million times harder.
Can I support stomach acid without betaine HCl?
Yes. I do not tolerate betaine HCl. I stopped drinking with meals, kept protein away from starch, ate enough good-quality salt and cooked my protein until it fell apart, and that was enough to rebuild my stomach acid.
Which digestive enzyme do you use for low stomach acid?
My favourite is Digest Gold by Enzymedica. It is a full-spectrum enzyme with a Thera-blend of proteases, which work at different pH ranges, so protein is still digested when stomach acid is low.
Why does broth help with low stomach acid?
Broth contains glutamine, glycosaminoglycans and other glycoproteins that help the stomach lining to heal. When the lining is stronger, the body feels safe to produce more acid. Broth also stimulates the appetite and stomach acid.
Next step
Find out which pillar of your digestion needs support.
Stomach acid is one of the five pillars of digestion. The free Gut Health Quiz shows which of yours needs attention, and the Gut Health Bundle takes you through each one, step by step.
Keep reading
I’m a coach, not a medical doctor. This article shares my experience and what I see with the clients I coach. It is for education only and is not medical advice, a diagnosis or a treatment plan. Speak to your doctor before changing medication or if your symptoms are severe or new.