Histamine intolerance vs MCAS (mast cell activation syndrome): the difference is where the histamine comes from. With histamine intolerance it comes from outside the body, from food or from gut bacteria, and there is more of it than you can break down. With MCAS it comes from inside. Your own mast cells release it, because something is irritating your immune system.

I had both. The symptoms overlap almost completely, which is why they are so often confused. Telling them apart matters, because it tells you where to work.

Key takeaways

  • Both involve the same molecule, histamine, so the symptoms look alike and vary from person to person.
  • Histamine intolerance: too much histamine arriving from food or gut bacteria, and too little capacity to break it down.
  • MCAS: mast cells releasing histamine because something keeps irritating the immune system.
  • How you respond to a low-histamine diet, DAO or digestive support gives useful clues.
  • With MCAS the first job is to find the irritant: a toxin in your environment, your gut, or long-term stress.

Why histamine intolerance and MCAS are so easily confused

Whether it is histamine intolerance or MCAS, the molecule causing the symptoms is histamine. So the symptoms cross over almost entirely.

They also differ from person to person. Some people get the classic picture: itching, especially around the face and eyes, hives or rashes, a blocked or runny nose. Others get insomnia, headaches or a churning gut. For me it was itchy, streaming eyes that felt as if something was in them, a crawling itch on my skin, anxiety, panic and very low mood.

That variety is why both are hard to pin down. A diagnosis depends on fitting set criteria, and many people do not fit neatly. Your symptoms do not have to match anyone else’s.

Histamine intolerance vs MCAS: the key difference

Histamine intolerance: histamine from outside

Here the histamine comes from your diet, or it is produced in your gut by bacteria. The inside of the gut is technically outside the body. It is a tube running through you, separated from the rest by a lining one cell thick. So both of these are external sources.

You break this histamine down in two ways: with DAO, an enzyme made in the gut lining, and with beneficial gut bacteria that degrade histamine. Histamine intolerance is what happens when the amount arriving is more than those two can handle.

MCAS: histamine from inside

With MCAS, something is irritating the immune system. Mast cells, which are part of it, become reactive and release histamine themselves. Nothing has to arrive from outside. The histamine is produced inside the body, faster than you can clear it.

Clues to which one you have

There are lab tests, and your doctor can advise on them. I find the pattern of your responses just as informative:

  • A low-histamine diet helps a lot. That points towards histamine intolerance.
  • A DAO supplement helps a lot. Also histamine intolerance.
  • A low-histamine diet takes symptoms from a ten to a four or five, and no further. Histamine is still coming from somewhere: from gut bacteria, or from your own mast cells.
  • Digestive support improves your symptoms. Then poor digestion is part of the cause. Undigested food is feeding histamine-producing bacteria, or crossing a leaky gut and provoking the immune system.
  • A mast cell stabiliser prescribed by your doctor clearly raises your tolerance, even to high-histamine foods. That points strongly to MCAS.
  • You react to almost everything, whatever you eat. That is more typical of MCAS.

Each of these is a small experiment. Put together, they show where the problem sits.

If it is histamine intolerance: what I work on

People have eaten aged and fermented food for thousands of years. Refrigeration is recent. So I do not see the food as the problem. The problem is that the ability to break histamine down has dropped, and the gut is making too much of its own.

Restore the microbes that degrade histamine. I usually start with a probiotic made of histamine-neutral and histamine-degrading strains, introduced slowly. For a minority, perhaps 20 to 30% in my experience, this is most of the answer. For everyone else it is still the foundation.

Fix how food is digested. Food that is not broken down feeds the wrong bacteria and wears at the gut lining, and that lowers your DAO. The free Gut Health Quiz shows which part of your digestion needs support.

DAO supplements and nutrients for the gut lining can help in the short term. They do not solve the underlying problem.

I go through this in detail in my guide to histamine intolerance.

If it is MCAS: find what is irritating the immune system

In every person with MCAS I have spoken to, something was irritating the immune system. The immune system does not misbehave for no reason. The work is to find that irritant.

A toxin in your environment

This is the cause in most cases I see, around 70 to 80%. Think of a low-level poison trickling into the body over a long time:

  • mold, in a water-damaged home or workplace, now or in the past;
  • dental issues, such as an infection or amalgam fillings;
  • chemicals at work. I have seen this in cleaners, hairdressers, a chemical engineer and people living beside sprayed farmland.

When the body’s main routes for clearing toxins are overloaded, the immune system steps in to protect you, and mast cells become reactive.

Your gut

The irritant can also come from within. Food that is only half digested, or fragments of gut bacteria, can pass through a leaky gut lining and set mast cells off.

If you react to particular foods, digestion is the likelier culprit. If you react to everything, look at your gut bacteria. This is also why some people feel better on a meat-only diet: it starves those bacteria. That controls symptoms. It does not solve the problem, and you carry it with you wherever you move.

Stress

Mast cells respond to the nervous system. If you feel unsafe, unsupported or worried about money day after day, the message they receive is “danger”.

If your symptoms ease whenever you take a real break, stress is part of your picture. That does not make it any less real.

Can you have both histamine intolerance and MCAS?

Yes, and it is common. I had both, along with mold illness. The same damaged gut that makes less DAO also lets more through to the immune system.

That is why I start with the gut whichever it turns out to be. Probiotics and digestion are part of both answers. With MCAS you also have to find and remove the irritant.

I now eat pizza with cheese and cured meat on top. A few years ago that was unthinkable. I cannot promise you the same result, but I do not treat either condition as something you simply have to live with.

Video: the talk this article is based on.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between histamine intolerance and MCAS?

The source of the histamine. With histamine intolerance it comes from food or from gut bacteria and you cannot break it down fast enough. With MCAS your own mast cells release it because something is irritating your immune system.

Can you have histamine intolerance and MCAS at the same time?

Yes. I had both, and many of the people I coach do too. A damaged gut lining lowers your ability to break histamine down and also lets more irritants through to the immune system.

How do I know whether I have histamine intolerance or MCAS?

Your doctor can advise on testing. The pattern of your responses also helps: if a low-histamine diet or DAO helps a great deal, that suggests histamine intolerance. If you react to almost everything regardless of diet, MCAS is more likely.

Does a low-histamine diet help MCAS?

It can reduce the load, but usually only partly, because with MCAS the histamine is being released inside your body. If diet takes you part of the way and no further, look for what is irritating your immune system.

What triggers MCAS?

In most cases I see, an ongoing low-level toxic exposure: mold, a dental issue or chemicals at work. The gut can be the source too, and so can long-term stress.

Can MCAS go away?

Mine improved enormously once I dealt with mold, my gut and the emotional side, and I have seen many others improve. I cannot promise an outcome. I do treat it as a problem with causes that can be found.

Next step

Want the full process, step by step?

My Histamine Intolerance & MCAS Recovery Protocol sets out how I work through diet, gut and mast cells, in order. If you would rather go through your own history with me, book a consultation.

See the protocolWork with me

Research mentioned in this article

William Dickinson, gut health coach

Written by

William Dickinson

I’m a gut health coach from the UK. I spent years unwell with gut, histamine and mold problems before I worked out how to turn them around, and I now coach clients worldwide through the same process. I have worked with more than 1,000 clients and taught over 425 online classes.

More about me

I’m a coach, not a medical doctor. This article shares my experience and what I see with the clients I coach. It is for education only and is not medical advice, a diagnosis or a treatment plan. Speak to your doctor before changing medication or if your symptoms are severe or new.