I have been there myself: I used to struggle with veganism and vegetarianism. My own health, and what I have learned since, changed my mind. I do not think veganism is the answer to our health or to the planet’s, and here I explain why. This is my view. What you eat is your decision.

If you follow a vegan diet, make sure you are covering nutrients such as vitamin B12, and get advice from a dietitian or your doctor if you are unsure.

Key takeaways

  • I tried it myself. My health changed my mind.
  • Some nutrients, such as vitamin B12, come mainly or only from animal foods.
  • Crop farming has environmental and animal costs of its own.
  • Local, seasonal food and well-kept animals are my preference.
  • What you eat is your own decision.

Health

A vegan diet has real benefits for some people, at least at first. I think part of that is similar to what happens in fasting: a lighter load on digestion for a while.

Fasting is good for most people in short spells, but nobody can do it indefinitely. In the same way, a vegan diet can feel wonderful at first, yet it is hard to get everything the body needs from it. Vitamin B12, haem iron, choline and retinol come mainly or only from animal foods. The word protein also hides a lot of detail. Proteins are made of amino acids, and the body needs specific ones, just as it needs specific vitamins.

Read this article too: Fasting for Beginners: Types, Benefits and How to Start Safely

Getting enough of those amino acids on a vegan diet takes real care. It also matters how usable a protein is, not just whether it is present.

What our physiology suggests

Our digestive system is that of an omnivore, well able to digest animal foods. I have written more about two related topics: fat-soluble vitamins and anti-nutrients in vegetables.

The environment

Veganism is often presented as the way to save the planet. I think the picture is more complicated.

Agriculture

Let’s begin by discussing how much food an herbivorous animal needs to consume compared to a carnivorous animal, and the nutrients extracted from that food. The herbivore needs to consume a significantly larger volume of food, and the nutrients they extract are significantly less than those of a carnivore. In most cases, this is not a problem and can be highly beneficial for the planet.

Cows graze and fertilise the ground all day, and their digestive system is built for it. When people eat only plants, they are not eating grass. They are eating crops grown as monocultures, on soil that is ploughed and tilled, which disturbs soil life and releases carbon. This article explains the effect of tilling.

The impact of tilling and agriculture on CO² levels is shown in the article, which suggests avoiding tilling and allowing pasture animals to graze as a solution. Animals, especially ruminants like cows and sheep, play a vital role in the earth’s ecosystem, and their manure serves numerous purposes. Tilling disrupts the earth’s microbiome, but ruminant manure is packed with beneficial bacteria for the soil. These animals are like factories for bacteria, as their digestive systems contain massive amounts of microorganisms.

Distribution

Shipping food around the world has an environmental cost. Some of it is necessary, but there is a big difference between shipping spices and shipping heavy, water-filled fruit such as pineapples, bananas and melons. I would rather most of what we eat every day was grown close to home.

Supplements and local food

A vegan diet usually needs supplements, B12 at the very least, and many people add protein powders and other products. Those have to be manufactured and shipped as well.

Luckily, we have a straightforward solution at our disposal – consuming local food sources. Wild edibles such as dandelion greens and mushrooms, seasonal fruits, and animals pastured in our backyards are all great options. By doing so, we can avoid shipping costs, maintain a natural diet, and obtain nutrient-dense food. Plus, we can ensure the animals have lived a happy life. In fact, I have a herd of cows nearby that I can hear from my bedroom! I can visit them, feed them cabbages, and scratch their heads without any concerns.

Ethics

I used to struggle with veganism and vegetarianism, unsure of what I was doing. I questioned why I should kill an animal to survive, feeling like I had no right to do so. However, as my health deteriorated, I realised that consuming animal products is necessary for our health. My belief that not harming animals was better for everyone was based on ego, and I now have a new approach based on fact and science.

I’ve come to grips with the concept of death and understand that it is a natural part of life. I appreciate the animals that provide me with sustenance and am grateful for their sacrifice. I take responsibility for the quality of life of the animals I consume and ensure that they have lived a natural and fulfilling life.

Where do we draw the line?

Growing crops harms animals too, and I find it hard to see where the line is meant to be drawn.

Cows? Yes.
rabbits? Obviously.
Mice? Erm, I suppose?
Crickets, insects and creepy crawlies? Hmmm maybe not?
Bacteria, fungi? No? Why not?

Pesticides, insecticides and harvesting machinery kill insects and small animals in large numbers. No way of eating is free of harm.

Everyone should be free to decide what they eat and how they live. Make up your own mind and do what is right for you. I hope this has given you something to think about.

Next step

Not sure which foods are the problem?

My free Comprehensive Food Sensitivities List covers the food groups people react to most, and why. If you want help working out your own plan, book a consultation.

Get the free listWork with me

William Dickinson, gut health coach

Written by

William Dickinson

I’m a gut health coach from the UK. I spent years unwell with gut, histamine and mold problems before I worked out how to turn them around, and I now coach clients worldwide through the same process. I have worked with more than 1,000 clients and taught over 425 online classes.

More about me

I’m a coach, not a medical doctor. This article shares my experience and what I see with the clients I coach. It is for education only and is not medical advice, a diagnosis or a treatment plan. Speak to your doctor before changing medication or if your symptoms are severe or new.

4 Comments

  1. Judy 25 October 2019at1:39 PM

    Congratulations! At last a rational look at the whole vegan/meat question. Just hope a lot of folk actually read it and understand.

    1. The Wizard 25 October 2019at12:51 PM

      Thankyou for your kind words; if you found it informative please share! Best way to spread important information is word of mouth

  2. Emma 13 January 2021at7:22 PM

    great overview, Billy, you have the hawk’s eye

    1. Billy Dickinson 16 January 2021at3:07 PM

      Thanks SO MUCH Emma. Your opinion holds much value in my heart ❤