Natural toothpaste alternatives are easy to make at home from a few ingredients: an oil base, something to clean and whiten, and an essential oil for freshness. I started making my own because I wanted to know exactly what I was putting in my mouth. Here is how I do it, and why what you eat matters at least as much as what you brush with.
This is what I use, not dental advice. Dentists recommend fluoride toothpaste to protect against decay, so talk to your dentist before you change your routine, and keep up your check-ups.
Key takeaways
- What you eat matters at least as much as what you brush with.
- A homemade toothpaste starts with an oil base such as sesame, olive or coconut oil.
- Bicarbonate of soda or activated charcoal can be added to whiten and freshen.
- Essential oils such as peppermint or clove add flavour.
- Talk to your dentist before changing your routine, especially about fluoride.
Diet comes first
Before the recipes, a word about diet. A diet high in sugar feeds the organisms in the mouth that produce acid and plaque, which leads to decay. A mineral-rich diet does the opposite. Greens, and broths made with bones and skin, provide magnesium, calcium and phosphorus.
Consuming too much sugar, particularly refined sugar, depletes magnesium stores needed for sugar metabolism[1]. Magnesium, along with calcium and phosphorus, gives bones and teeth strength and durability. These minerals, along with collagen, are essential to include in your diet. Best sources are greens and meat, especially animal skin or broths. Vitamin D and K2 are important for telling minerals to enter the bone tissue[2]. Animal products like fatty grass-fed pastured egg yolks and butter and wild fish, such as salmon, mackerel, and sardines, are the best foods for these vitamins. I have a whole post explaining the importance of fat soluble nutrients! Don’t forget that sun exposure is the best source of vitamin D.
I’m going to design this recipe format a little differently. You can add, replace, or remove ingredients based on your toothpaste goals. Mix and match to find your perfect combination.
Making your own
I start with an oil base. Essential oils are usually added for fresh breath, and they mix evenly into oil.
Sesame oil is the traditional choice for oil pulling, an old practice of swishing oil around the mouth. Olive oil and coconut oil work too, although coconut oil sets hard when it is cold.
You can use the same base for oil pulling: swish a tablespoon around your mouth, then spit it out. Do not swallow it.
Whitening and freshening (optional)
Once you have a base, you can add something to whiten and deodorise. Activated charcoal and bicarbonate of soda are the usual options. You do not need much: about one heaped tablespoon per cup of base. Both are mildly abrasive, so brush gently.
Flavour (optional)
Essential oils add flavour and scent. Mint and peppermint are the popular choices, and clove is a good one to try. My dad makes his with olive oil and oil of oregano and swears by it.
Extras (optional)
For a sweeter taste, add a little stevia or xylitol. Neither feeds the bacteria in the mouth, and xylitol in particular has been studied for its effect on them[3].
Next step
Not sure where to start with your health?
Start with your gut. The free Gut Health Quiz takes a few minutes and shows which part of your digestion needs attention.
Keep reading
I’m a coach, not a medical doctor. This article shares my experience and what I see with the clients I coach. It is for education only and is not medical advice, a diagnosis or a treatment plan. Speak to your doctor before changing medication or if your symptoms are severe or new.