You are ready to reintroduce foods after an elimination diet when two things are true: your body can digest them, and you feel safe enough to be curious about them. Most advice only deals with the first. In my experience, with my own diet and with clients, the second is where people stay stuck for years.

I ate five or six foods for about five years. This is the process I used to get back to eating almost everything, and the one I use with the people I coach.

Key takeaways

  • A reaction to a food has one of two roots: your body cannot digest it yet, or part of you is afraid of what happens if you eat it.
  • Start with a food close to what you already tolerate, in its simplest form, at a teaspoon to a tablespoon.
  • Use food combining at the start so your digestion can focus on one new thing.
  • The fear is rarely of the food itself. It is of the reaction, and of how you treat yourself when a reaction comes.
  • The right moment is when curiosity has become stronger than fear. That cannot be forced.

Two reasons a food can still cause a reaction

I always look at health on two levels, physical and emotional. Food reactions are no different.

Physical: can your body break this food down, digest it and absorb it, without setting off a reaction? If yes, you are close.

Emotional: is there resistance to eating it? You may not feel it as fear or anxiety. It can show up only in the body, as symptoms. If the resistance is there and you are not aware of it, you can react to a food your gut is perfectly able to digest.

You need to cover both, because fixing one does nothing for the other.

The physical side: give the food its best chance

Start with a relative of something you already eat

Your body uses a particular set of digestive machinery for each type of food. If you already eat rice and potatoes, you have some of what you need for pasta or sourdough, and your chances are good. If you have not eaten any starch for years, treat it as a category you rebuild slowly.

Choose the easiest form to digest

Keep the variables low. Crisps and shop chips bring seasonings, flavourings and vegetable oil with them, so a reaction tells you nothing. Plain boiled potato, mashed with salt, is a much better test. For rice, cook it right down and blend it into a purée, the way you would for a baby.

Start with a teaspoon to a tablespoon

No more than that the first time. You are asking a question, not eating a meal.

Use food combining at the start

Different foods need different digestive conditions. When you introduce something new, let your body focus on that one food instead of several groups at once. I explain the rules in my guide to food combining.

What a reaction is telling you

If you have prepared the food well and kept the amount small, there are two outcomes. Either you are fine, and the food is back in your diet. Or you react.

A reaction means one of two things. Your body cannot process that food yet, in which case leave it for now and keep working on your digestion. Or the cause is emotional, and then no amount of careful preparation will change the result, because that is not where the problem is.

The emotional side: fear of the reaction, not the food

When food has made you ill for a long time, you end up with two parts of yourself in conflict. One wants the ice cream, the popcorn or the potato. The other is afraid of what will happen afterwards.

Notice what that second part is afraid of. It is not the food. It is the reaction, and very often it is how you behave when a reaction comes.

My own pattern looked like this. A reaction felt as if my digestion had switched off, so my rule was to eat nothing for the next 24 hours. I cancelled my work, told everyone to leave me alone and shut myself away. Those rules helped me cope when I was very ill. Later, when my body could digest far more, the rules were still running, and the part of me that hated them kept producing the reaction.

Change what happens when a reaction comes

Ask yourself honestly what you do after a reaction, and what that frightened part would need instead. For me the answers were simple. Eat when I am hungry again. Do not isolate. Ask for comfort. Move a call instead of cancelling everything. Once I had agreed to those things, the fear was still there, but nothing in me was against trying.

Wait for curiosity

A child who feels unsafe goes still. A child who feels safe is into everything. It is the same here. When there is enough safety, curiosity appears on its own: “I might react. But what if I don’t?”

When curiosity has just overtaken fear, that is the right time to try.

If food has become frightening, your diet is down to very few foods, or you are losing weight, please do not work through this alone. Speak to your doctor or a qualified therapist.

After the first success: learning the new rules

The first time I ate ice cream with no reaction, the rules I had lived by for years fell apart in a moment. Could I have coffee? Pasta? Gluten? That is exciting, and it is also unsettling.

A few days later I ate half a bag of pistachios and had a miserable stomach ache. My instinct was to restrict everything again. Instead I asked what made sense. Nuts are hard to digest, and I had not eaten fibre for five years. That was a physical limit, not proof that everything was unsafe. The next meal, fish and rice, was fine.

From there I mapped the new rules one food at a time. Gluten, dairy and fruit were fine. Nuts, seeds, beans and legumes needed soaking and sprouting, and small amounts. A year and a half later I can eat more of them, and I am still building that capacity. It comes back in layers.

Video: the full talk this article is based on.

How to reintroduce foods after an elimination diet, step by step

  1. Pick a food that is close to something you already tolerate.
  2. Prepare it in its plainest, easiest-to-digest form.
  3. Check in with yourself. If fear is stronger than curiosity, work on the safety net first.
  4. Decide in advance how you will look after yourself if you react.
  5. Eat a teaspoon to a tablespoon, away from other food groups.
  6. If it goes well, you have new evidence. Build on it slowly.
  7. If you react, ask whether it makes physical sense. If it does, wait and try again later.

Frequently asked questions

How do I know when I am ready to reintroduce a food?

When your digestion has improved enough to handle it and you feel more curious than afraid about trying it. If the thought of eating it still brings mostly fear, work on feeling safe first.

Which food should I reintroduce first?

One that is close to something you already eat. If you tolerate rice, potato is a sensible next step. Prepare it as plainly as possible, for example boiled and mashed with salt.

How much should I eat the first time?

A teaspoon to a tablespoon. Eat it away from other food groups so your digestion can focus on it, and so you know what caused any reaction.

What should I do if I react to a reintroduced food?

Look after yourself in the way you agreed beforehand, then ask whether the reaction makes physical sense. If the food is hard to digest, leave it for now and try again later. One reaction does not mean every food is unsafe.

Why do I still react to foods I should be able to digest?

In my experience the cause is often emotional. After years of reactions, part of you expects the worst and the body responds with symptoms. Changing how you treat yourself when a reaction comes is what shifted this for me.

How long does food reintroduction take?

It varies a lot. It comes back in layers, and harder foods such as nuts, seeds and legumes take longest. A year and a half after my own breakthrough I was still increasing some of them.

Next step

Not sure which foods are the problem?

My free Comprehensive Food Sensitivities List covers the food groups people react to most and why. If you want help working out your own order of reintroduction, book a consultation.

Get the free listWork with me

William Dickinson, gut health coach

Written by

William Dickinson

I’m a gut health coach from the UK. I spent years unwell with gut, histamine and mold problems before I worked out how to turn them around, and I now coach clients worldwide through the same process. I have worked with more than 1,000 clients and taught over 425 online classes.

More about me

I’m a coach, not a medical doctor. This article shares my experience and what I see with the clients I coach. It is for education only and is not medical advice, a diagnosis or a treatment plan. Speak to your doctor before changing medication or if your symptoms are severe or new.